Skip to content

Real delivery dates before you pay

Free shipping over $35.00

30-day returns · Right-size promise

Play a game, win up to 17% off

Northern Wag

Walks & training

Harness or collar? What the research says

What studies found about neck pressure and pulling, which dogs should always use a harness, and why a collar still has a job.

By the Northern Wag teamUpdated September 30, 20263 min read
Two dogs walk side by side, one in a padded harness and one in a flat collar.

AI-generated illustration. Product photos on our product pages are real photos of what ships.

The short answer

  • A collar concentrates pressure on the neck; a harness spreads it across the chest.
  • Small dogs, flat-faced breeds and dogs with tracheal or neck problems should walk on a harness.
  • A back-clip harness doesn't stop pulling by itself. Training does.
  • Most dogs should still wear a collar or tag for ID, even if they walk on a harness.
On this page (6 sections)
  1. What a collar does to the neck
  2. What a harness changes
  3. Who should always use a harness
  4. What to look for in a harness
  5. Why your dog still needs a collar
  6. Fit check

It's one of the most common questions in any dog shop, and the answer is refreshingly clear for most dogs: walk on a harness, wear a collar for ID. Here's why.

What a collar does to the neck

When a dog pulls on a collar, all the force lands on a narrow band around the neck, over the windpipe, the neck muscles and the blood vessels to the head. Veterinary research links collar pressure to:

  • Tracheal irritation, and worsening of tracheal collapse, which is common in small breeds such as Yorkshire terriers, Pomeranians and chihuahuas.
  • Raised pressure inside the eye. A study measuring intraocular pressure found it rose when dogs pulled against a collar, which matters for dogs with glaucoma or thin corneas.
  • Neck strain from repeated jolts, especially with sudden lunges.

What a harness changes

A harness spreads the same force across the chest and shoulders. That's more comfortable, and it takes the windpipe out of the equation.

Who should always use a harness

DogWhy
Toy and small breedsDelicate windpipes, and higher risk of tracheal collapse
Flat-faced breeds (pugs, French bulldogs)Already work harder to breathe
Dogs with neck, spine or eye conditionsKeeps pressure off the neck and head
Strong pullers and lungersSpreads force away from the throat
Dogs who slip collarsA well-fitted harness is harder to back out of

What to look for in a harness

  • Padding on the chest plate so pressure doesn't dig in
  • Adjustable neck and chest straps for a snug fit
  • A top handle for helping over snowbanks and in and out of cars
  • Reflective stitching for dark evenings
  • Quick-release buckles so it goes on in seconds
In our shopTrailhead Padded HarnessPadded chest plate, reflective stitching, top grab handle and two quick-release buckles.

Why your dog still needs a collar

A harness is for walks. A collar holds your dog's ID tag and licence the rest of the time. Most Canadian cities require dogs to be licensed, and an ID tag is the fastest way home for a lost dog. Keep the collar on, clip the leash to the harness.

Fit check

You should fit two fingers flat under every strap. The harness shouldn't slide into the armpits or rub behind the front legs. Not sure about size? Our measuring guide shows exactly where to measure.

If pulling is the real problem, read how to stop your dog pulling on the leash next.

Free toolSize finderMeasurements or breed in, the right harness, jacket, boot and collar size out.

Questions people ask

Is a harness better than a collar?

For walking, a well-fitted harness is kinder to the neck because it spreads pressure over the chest. It matters most for small dogs, flat-faced breeds and dogs that pull.

Do harnesses make dogs pull more?

A study that measured pulling found dogs pulled with more force on a back-clip harness than on a collar, likely because it's more comfortable. A harness is a comfort and safety tool; loose-leash training is what stops pulling.

Can my dog wear a harness all day?

It's better to take it off at home. Harnesses left on all day can rub and trap moisture. Keep a collar with ID on instead.

Sources we checked

  1. Frontiers in Veterinary Science (2021): Dog pulling on the leash, neck collar vs chest harness
  2. Effect of a collar and harness on intraocular pressure (Veterinary Medicine and Science)

Written by Northern Wag in Calgary and checked against the sources above. This is general information, not veterinary advice: if you're worried about your dog, call your vet.

All guides